Vectorising with Rcompadre

Introduction

COM(P)ADRE databases contain thousands of matrix population models. If we want to derive traits from a large set of these matrices, we’ll need to use either loops or vectorisation.

Vectorising means applying a function to each element of a vector. Here vector is defined broadly - it could be a sequence of character strings, a column of a data.frame, a list of matrices, etc. Vectorised code generally runs faster than loops, and many R users find that vectorised code is easier to write and understand.

Preliminaries

We’ll start by loading a few packages and a dataset that we’ll be using throughout this vignette. The dataset Compadre is a subset of a recent COMPADRE release that’s built into Rcompadre.

library(Rcompadre)
library(popdemo)
#> Welcome to popdemo! This is version 1.3-0
#> Use ?popdemo for an intro, or browseVignettes('popdemo') for vignettes
#> Citation for popdemo is here: doi.org/10.1111/j.2041-210X.2012.00222.x
#> Development and legacy versions are here: github.com/iainmstott/popdemo
data(Compadre)

Introduction to vectorisation

To understand vectorisation, we first need a vector. For this purpose, we’ll extract a list of A matrices from the mat column of Compadre, and add this list of matrices to Compadre as a new column.

Compadre$matA <- matA(Compadre)

This new column, Compadre$matA, is both a vector and a list.

is.vector(Compadre$matA) # it really is a vector
#> [1] TRUE
is.list(Compadre$matA) # and also a list
#> [1] TRUE
length(Compadre$matA) # with 150 matrices
#> [1] 150
Compadre$matA[1:3] # here are the first three
#> [[1]]
#>      A1   A2   A3   A4
#> A1 0.61 0.38 0.30 1.16
#> A2 0.23 0.50 0.31 0.32
#> A3 0.00 0.18 0.54 0.41
#> A4 0.00 0.05 0.08 0.50
#> 
#> [[2]]
#>        A1    A2    A3       A4       A5        A6
#> A1 0.8430 0.000 0.000 176.0600 635.7200 1601.2500
#> A2 0.0003 0.000 0.000   0.0584   0.2109    0.5313
#> A3 0.0000 0.476 0.132   0.1430   0.0000    0.0560
#> A4 0.0000 0.095 0.105   0.2860   0.0000    0.0000
#> A5 0.0000 0.167 0.474   0.4290   0.8000    0.0000
#> A6 0.0000 0.143 0.237   0.0710   0.2000    0.8890
#> 
#> [[3]]
#>       A1    A2    A3
#> A1 0.017 0.000 1.142
#> A2 0.655 0.902 0.009
#> A3 0.000 0.001 0.988

Let’s say we want to calculate the dimension of every matrix in Compadre$matA. In fact, Compadre already has this data in the column ‘MatrixDimension’, but let’s say we want to double-check it. We’ll use the function nrow(), and assume that the number of rows and columns are equal. But we can’t use nrow() directly on Compadre$matA, because the function nrow() isn’t vectorised. It can only take one object at a time.

Manual approach

We could do something like this…

Compadre$dim <- numeric(nrow(Compadre)) # create empty vector to store output
Compadre$dim[1] <- nrow(Compadre$matA[[1]]) # nrow matrix 1
Compadre$dim[2] <- nrow(Compadre$matA[[2]]) # nrow matrix 2
Compadre$dim[3] <- nrow(Compadre$matA[[3]]) # nrow matrix 3
# ... all the way to 150

But that’s not very efficient for 150 matrices.

Loop approach

A loop would be much more efficient here.

# create empty vector to store output
Compadre$dim <- numeric(nrow(Compadre))

# loop through all rows of Compadre
for (i in seq_len(nrow(Compadre))) {
  Compadre$dim[i] <- nrow(Compadre$matA[[i]])
}

Vectorised approach

An even nicer approach is to vectorise the function nrow() over the vector Compadre$matA using sapply().

Compadre$dim <- sapply(Compadre$matA, nrow)

sapply() applies the function specified in the 2nd argument (nrow()) to every element of the vector in the first argument (Compadre$matA), and returns a vector of the results. The advantage of sapply() over the loop is that we don’t need to pre-define an object to store the results.

Vectorising custom functions

We can also vectorise with a custom function. Let’s say we want to know, for every matrix, whether there are stages with no transitions (i.e. any column sums equal to zero). Here’s a vectorised approach.

# function to determine whether matrix 'mat' has any stages with no transitions
NullStages <- function(mat) any(colSums(mat) == 0)

# apply function to every element of A
Compadre$null_stages <- sapply(Compadre$matA, NullStages)

The key to vectorising is to make sure the function works on individual elements of the vector.

NullStages(Compadre$matA[[1]]) # apply function to single element

Accessor functions and vectorisation

Note that, in the example above, it wasn’t necessary to create the column Compadre$matA before vectorising over the A matrices. We could have simply used the matA() accessor within sapply().

Compadre$null_stages <- sapply(matA(Compadre), NullStages)

Using `cdb_unnest()` to avoid accessors

That said, using accessor funtions can get tedious. Rather than constantly using accessor functions to extract components of the mat column, we could use the function cdb_unnest() to extract separate columns for all matrix components at the start of our analysis.

# create new columns matA, matU, matF, matC, MatrixClassAuthor, etc..
CompUnnest <- cdb_unnest(Compadre)

Then we can refer to any component using $, e.g.

# apply NullStages to every matA
CompUnnest$null_stages <- sapply(CompUnnest$matA, NullStages)

# count number of dormant stages in every MatrixClassOrganized
NumberDormant <- function(stages) length(which(stages == "dorm"))
CompUnnest$n_dormant <- sapply(CompUnnest$MatrixClassOrganized, NumberDormant)

Other apply functions

vapply() is similar to sapply(), except that the output type is specified as an argument.

sapply(CompUnnest$matA[1:6], nrow)
#> [1] 4 6 3 5 5 3
vapply(CompUnnest$matA[1:6], nrow, numeric(1)) # must specify output type
#> [1] 4 6 3 5 5 3

lapply() always returns a list, so it’s useful if our output is more complex than a single value for each input. For example, we could use lapply to calculate vectors of stage-specific survival (column sums of matU).

lapply(CompUnnest$matU[1:4], function(m) colSums(m))
#> [[1]]
#>   U1   U2   U3   U4 
#> 0.84 0.73 0.93 0.91 
#> 
#> [[2]]
#>     U1     U2     U3     U4     U5     U6 
#> 0.8433 0.8810 0.9480 0.9290 1.0000 0.9450 
#> 
#> [[3]]
#>    U1    U2    U3 
#> 0.672 0.903 0.997 
#> 
#> [[4]]
#>      U1      U2      U3      U4      U5 
#> 0.83820 0.82850 0.75345 0.86665 0.05000

mapply() is for vectorising over multiple arguments. For example, the lifeExpectancy() function below (taken from the package Rage) calculates life expectancy given two arguments: a U matrix, and an integer indicator for the stage class reflecting the ‘start of life’. The start of life is often defined as the first ‘active’ stage class (i.e. not propagule or dormant), the index of which will vary from row to row.

# function to calculate life expectancy
lifeExpectancy <- function(matU, startLife) {
  N <- solve(diag(nrow(matU)) - matU)
  return(colSums(N)[startLife])
}

# get index of first active stage class with mpm_first_active()
CompUnnest$start_life <- mpm_first_active(CompUnnest)

# vectorise lifeExpectancy over matU and start_life
mapply(
  lifeExpectancy, # function
  CompUnnest$matU[1:6], # first argument to vectorise over
  CompUnnest$start_life[1:6]
) # second argument to vectorise over
#>        U1        U2        U1        U1        U1        U1 
#>  5.727060 22.194872  8.439966  3.009829 10.877215 18.181818

When functions fail

Just like loops, vectorisation fails if the function being vectorised throws an error on any element of the vector. Here’s an example. The eigs() function from popdemo calculates the expected population growth rate given a projection matrix. It’ll work on most of the A matrices in Compadre, but fails on matrices that contain missing values (NA).

# works for a single matrix
popdemo::eigs(CompUnnest$matA[[1]], what = "lambda")
#> [1] 1.058029

# but fails when applied to all matrices because a few have missing values
CompUnnest$lambda <- sapply(CompUnnest$matA, popdemo::eigs, what = "lambda")
#> Error in eigen(A): infinite or missing values in 'x'

There are two basic approaches to overcoming this:

1. Remove or skip problem elements

If eigs() doesn’t work on matrices with missing values, one approach is to simply remove matrices with missing values. The cdb_flag() function is an easy way to check for missing values, and other common issues that might hinder our analyses.

# add column 'check_NA_A', indicating whether matA contains missing values (T/F)
CompFlag <- cdb_flag(CompUnnest, checks = "check_NA_A")

# remove rows where matA contains missing values
CompSub <- subset(CompFlag, check_NA_A == FALSE)

# apply lambda() to every remaining matA
CompSub$lambda <- sapply(matA(CompSub), popdemo::eigs, what = "lambda")
#> Warning in FUN(X[[i]], ...): More than one eigenvalues have equal absolute
#> magnitude

Alternatively, if we want to avoid subsetting, we could pre-define a placeholder column for the result, and then selectively apply the eigs() function to only those matrices that don’t contain missing values.

# identify rows with no missing values in matA
no_missing <- which(CompFlag$check_NA_A == FALSE)

# create placeholder column for lambda
CompFlag$lambda <- NA

# apply eigs() to all matA with no missing values
CompFlag$lambda[no_missing] <- sapply(CompFlag$matA[no_missing],
  popdemo::eigs,
  what = "lambda"
)
#> Warning in FUN(X[[i]], ...): More than one eigenvalues have equal absolute
#> magnitude

Rows where there were missing values in matA retain the original placeholder value of NA.

2. Modify the function

A second approach is to modify the function we want to vectorise with so that it can natively handle special cases. For example, we might modify eigs() so that it returns NA if a matrix contains missing values.

lambdaFn1 <- function(mat) {
  # check mat for missing values: if TRUE return NA, else return eigs(mat)
  ifelse(anyNA(mat), NA, popdemo::eigs(mat, what = "lambda"))
}

CompUnnest$lambda <- sapply(CompUnnest$matA, lambdaFn1)
#> Warning in popdemo::eigs(mat, what = "lambda"): More than one eigenvalues have
#> equal absolute magnitude

If the special cases are harder to test for, we could use R’s condition-handling functions like try() or tryCatch(). Here’s an example.

lambdaFn2 <- function(mat) {
  # try eigs(mat): if error return NA
  tryCatch(eigs(mat, what = "lambda"), error = function(err) NA)
}

CompUnnest$lambda <- sapply(CompUnnest$matA, lambdaFn2)
#> Warning in eigs(mat, what = "lambda"): More than one eigenvalues have equal
#> absolute magnitude

This latter approach requires caution, as we’ll get an NA for any error. Some errors might reflect problems with our data or code that are fixable, in which case an NA may be misleading.

Patrick Barks

2024-10-16

Introduction

Preliminaries

Introduction to vectorisation

Manual approach

Loop approach

Vectorised approach

Vectorising custom functions

Accessor functions and vectorisation

Using `cdb_unnest()` to avoid accessors

Other apply functions

When functions fail

1. Remove or skip problem elements

2. Modify the function

Vectorising with Rcompadre

Patrick Barks

2024-10-16

Introduction

Preliminaries

Introduction to vectorisation

Manual approach

Loop approach

Vectorised approach

Vectorising custom functions

Accessor functions and vectorisation

Using cdb_unnest() to avoid accessors

Other apply functions

When functions fail

1. Remove or skip problem elements

2. Modify the function

Using `cdb_unnest()` to avoid accessors